# Caraway: what people say on TikTok, Reddit, YouTube, X

Read 217 posts and comments on 2026-11-14; 145 were about Caraway. Full report with links: https://sociallisteningai.com/samples/brand-caraway/

Caraway's biggest strength is its look: people love the colors and design-forward styling, and the PFAS-free, non-toxic positioning gives buyers a feel-good reason to upgrade. The recurring problem is durability—the ceramic nonstick coating wears, scratches, and starts sticking within months to a couple of years, and some say warranty and support let them down. Price is a constant sticking point, and many compare Caraway unfavorably with stainless steel like All-Clad as a longer-term investment. A surprising credibility issue is influencer partnerships with people who don't cook, which makes some shoppers see the brand as style over substance.

**How it feels** (145 on-topic): 33% positive, 31% negative, 5% mixed, 31% neutral.
- TikTok: 52 (60% positive, 10% negative)
- Reddit: 57 (9% positive, 65% negative)
- X: 16 (69% positive, 0% negative)
- YouTube: 20 (5% positive, 15% negative)

Not included this time: Instagram (the source did not answer).

## What people like

- **the colorful, design-forward look makes it feel like a kitchen upgrade** (6 mentions)
  - "Looking for the perfect holiday gift for someone who loves cooking? Caraway cookware is definitely one of my favorite kitchen essentials! I love the beautiful, …" TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@rosey908_/video/7707881674926722317
  - "the cookware upgrade your kitchen was waiting for 30 Caraway ceramic cookware gives you a sleek, modern set that looks just as good on the stove as it does in t…" TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@liv_pip/video/7707379503684783374
- **non-toxic, PFAS-free materials are a key selling point** (5 mentions)
  - "Start married life off right with quality, top-performing cookware from Caraway. Made with premium materials and without PFAS. SAVE an extra 10% off site-wide with code reviewwire10 >> https://t.co/VTceIXCA6S #Wedd…" X https://x.com/TheReviewWire/status/2074582734513537158
  - " Visit the #Caraway Store Caraway 12-Piece Non-Stick #Ceramic #Cookware #Set #Pots, #Pans, Lids, #Kitchen #Storage, PFAS Free, #Oven Safe Pan Set, Compatible with All #Stovetops, Amazon Exclusive Brick Red #Chef #Cookin…" X https://x.com/travels007/status/2119615603485098405
- **the pans look beautiful and the colors are a draw** (5 mentions)
  - "These are stunning" TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@rialapae/video/7680976525860162830
  - "Oml these are beautiful" TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@rialapae/video/7680976525860162830
- **fans are loyal and buy whatever the brand recommends** (4 mentions)
  - "I’m @Caraway Home’s biggest fan (no this isn’t sponsored & ya I’ve got the receipts to prove it!!!) #carawaypans #carawayreview #cookwareset #splurgeworthy #buy…" TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@katerobbllc/video/7703308335168113934
  - "Just asked Santa!" TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@katerobbllc/video/7703308335168113934
- **the ceramic coating is better than other non-toxic options and holds up for years** (3 mentions)
  - "Ceramic cookware indeed wears down over time. But that is the case with any non-stick material. Ceramic at least is the best non toxic option. Teflon as everyone already knows is not a good option for your health but it …" Reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/UninfluencedReviews/comments/1sjhjol/feedback_on_caraway_cookware_are_they_any_good/ofzo9qg/
  - "I’ve had mine for years and still enjoy using them but stainless is the better investment." Reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/UninfluencedReviews/comments/1sjhjol/feedback_on_caraway_cookware_are_they_any_good/ofshcho/
- **the 12-piece set with matching storage is a convenient all-in-one buy** (3 mentions)
  - "Your sign to upgrade the scratched-up cookware situation 👀 This Caraway 12-piece set is non-stick, oven safe, works on all stovetops, and comes with storage. L…" TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@meganhil/video/7707653857374915871
  - "The caraway 12 piece ceramic nonstick cooker set is a kitchen upgrade worth checking out! Beautiful, non-toxic ceramic coated pots and pans with matching store …" TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@prettyreeljen/video/7706645298877140238
- **good holiday gift and wedding registry item** (3 mentions)
  - "Start married life off right with quality, top-performing cookware from Caraway. Made with premium materials and without PFAS. SAVE an extra 10% off site-wide with code reviewwire10 >> https://t.co/VTceIXCA6S #Wedd…" X https://x.com/TheReviewWire/status/2074582734513537158
  - "Cozy rainy nights call for @Caraway Home cooking nights 🤍 makes for a perfect holiday gift! #tiktokshopblackfriday #discoveryourgift #carawaycookware #househol…" TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@raveypavey/video/7707654674257677599

## Complaints and problems

- **ceramic nonstick coating wears out fast, often within months to a year** (9 mentions)
  - "I have heard from many people that after a year they turn to crap. Invest in stainless steel like allclad" Reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/UninfluencedReviews/comments/1sjhjol/feedback_on_caraway_cookware_are_they_any_good/ofrwp31/
  - "It’s just an aluminum pan with a ceramic non-stick coating. The non-stick layer goes away quickly, especially if you ever use high heat. Either buy cheap non-stick pans since they don’t last long or learn how to cook wit…" Reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/cookware/comments/1tpbk43/caraway_pans_can_eat_my_actual_ass/oo7h1zo/
- **influencer partnerships with people who don't cook hurt credibility** (5 mentions)
  - "![img](o7a5wekng8ch1) can someone please explain to me how a cookware company like Caraway is looking at this shit and thinking “yeah, that’s a person we want promoting our products”??? like that tells me I do not need t…" Reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/LaurenSimsSnarkv3/comments/1urpn1k/the_daily_july_09_2026/
  - "Anything KD is trying to sell or supporting is a big fat no for me. A while ago I think it was caraway cookware, I was really interested in that line and then I saw she was promoting it that killed it for me." Reddit https://www.reddit.com/gallery/1vnsddp
- **the coating degrades, scratches and gouges within a year or two** (4 mentions)
  - "Yep. Total waste of my money. I had such high hopes for them and they suck 😡" Reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/cookware/comments/1tpbk43/caraway_pans_can_eat_my_actual_ass/oohbbw5/
  - "Caraway. After browsing a bit it seems like the consensus is this brand is made in China and sucks. They don't have a phone support option of course and I understand it's a 1 year warranty (spouse made the choice 1.5 yea…" Reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/cookware/comments/1qvx9hl/caraway/
- **food sticks and pans become unusable, forcing replacement** (4 mentions)
  - "That’s called an old nonstick pan that needs to be thrown out." Reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/cookware/comments/1tpbk43/caraway_pans_can_eat_my_actual_ass/oo7ix5w/
  - "You need to stop using that pan yesterday. Time to ditch non stick." Reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/cookware/comments/1tpbk43/caraway_pans_can_eat_my_actual_ass/oo7q33r/
- **pans are heavy and overpriced for what you get** (4 mentions)
  - "Caraway sucks and is stupid heavy for no reason! I’m sure France has optimal cookware but she can’t shill that!" Reddit https://i.redd.it/2e4eorxrwyeh1.jpeg
  - "Caraway pans can eat my actual ass. Like are we serious????? Biggest waste of money of my life!!" Reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/cookware/comments/1tpbk43/caraway_pans_can_eat_my_actual_ass/
- **food sticks badly and is hard to clean; bottoms stain and discolor** (2 mentions)
  - "Caraway. After browsing a bit it seems like the consensus is this brand is made in China and sucks. They don't have a phone support option of course and I understand it's a 1 year warranty (spouse made the choice 1.5 yea…" Reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/cookware/comments/1qvx9hl/caraway/
  - "Caraway does not honor their one year warranty. One of our pans was not "non-stick", however they refused to replace it with only 3 months of usage." YouTube https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q4cdoKd1Dcc&lc=UgxCYqKbn743xX1VOuR4AaABAg
- **claims of non-toxic are seen as a marketing gimmick; tests found heavy metals** (2 mentions)
  - "I call bullshit on one of her family members having cancer. She literally asked chat gpt for some ideas how to shill that cookware. And if that’s true that someone in her family had cancer.. well she’s still disgusting c…" Reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/BrookeRaybouldSnark/comments/1ve7mkh/weekly_snark_8389/
  - "I would not use anything from Caraway because of heavy metal contamination issues. I’m sure they found a way to stick some lead into this machine as well. Simply Good Coffee etc are all plastic free, cheaper and much bet…" Reddit https://i.redd.it/l1kdagorhpth1.jpeg

## Questions people ask

- **how does it compare to HexClad, GreenPan, Our Place, Quince and Ninja?** (6 mentions)
  - "HexClad vs. Caraway: I Compared Both Cookware Sets to See Which One Is the Better Deal https://t.co/J9MVSeLURf" X https://x.com/thekitchn/status/2101698012666122689
  - "Caraway vs Our Place Cookware | Is One of These your Forever Brand? (2026)" YouTube https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WFl667P7GVQ
- **does the stainless steel line exist and is it good** (5 mentions)
  - "Omg I didn’t know they had stainless steel 😍😍 please make a review once you have used them a few times" TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@rialapae/video/7680976525860162830
  - "Could you do a review? You’re the first person to actual show me these and now I’m invested!! Trying to buy my first pan set x" TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@rialapae/video/7680976525860162830
- **do they actually last beyond a year or two in real use** (4 mentions)
  - "Feedback on Caraway cookware? Are they any good?. Hey, has anyone used Caraway cookware? They look really good, but I don't know how they do when actually in use and how do they last. I just moved to a new place and and …" Reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/UninfluencedReviews/comments/1sjhjol/feedback_on_caraway_cookware_are_they_any_good/
  - "is the hype real for the long term? looking for the best caraway cookware in 2026. i keep seeing caraway ads everywhere – the aesthetic is definitely on point for my kitchen, and the ceramic non-stick sounds great. but i…" Reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/Renters/comments/1q8nlrv/is_the_hype_real_for_the_long_term_looking_for/
- **is the brand actually any good, or just hype?** (3 mentions)
  - "Ceramic cookware indeed wears down over time. But that is the case with any non-stick material. Ceramic at least is the best non toxic option. Teflon as everyone already knows is not a good option for your health but it …" Reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/UninfluencedReviews/comments/1sjhjol/feedback_on_caraway_cookware_are_they_any_good/ofzo9qg/
  - "What does this mean exactly?" Reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/UninfluencedReviews/comments/1sjhjol/feedback_on_caraway_cookware_are_they_any_good/oft6o4j/
- **is the price worth it versus cheaper sets** (3 mentions)
  - "I was looking at these but I couldn’t do the $600-800 😭 and I wanted a big set not buy separately 😵‍💫 I got my ninja stainless steel set for under $300😭 I love them, I also use princess house a lot too" TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@rialapae/video/7680976525860162830
  - "Feedback on Caraway cookware? Are they any good?. Hey, has anyone used Caraway cookware? They look really good, but I don't know how they do when actually in use and how do they last. I just moved to a new place and and …" Reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/UninfluencedReviews/comments/1sjhjol/feedback_on_caraway_cookware_are_they_any_good/
- **which set or pieces to buy, and are single pieces worth it** (3 mentions)
  - "trying to figure out the best Caraway cookware deals right now. so i’ve been slowly fixing up my small apartment kitchen and i’ve been eyeing Caraway stuff for a while. a friend let me try their pan when i visited and ho…" Reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/Cooking/comments/1pifae5/trying_to_figure_out_the_best_caraway_cookware/
  - "Got a Caraway Gift Card - what should I do?. Hi folks. I won a Caraway "set" in my work's holiday raffle. Turns out, that means just sending me a $500 gift card. I've read all the posts about how the ceramic pans aren't …" Reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/cookware/comments/1pzxrh8/got_a_caraway_gift_card_what_should_i_do/
- **how to clean a stained ceramic pan without damaging it** (1 mention)
  - "Ceramic Caraway pan, already soaked overnight. Hi all I need some help with this pan. I already soaked it overnight with baking soda I also tried boiling and simmering with baking soda. Some of it definitely came off but…" Reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/CleaningTips/comments/1qtw5dy/ceramic_caraway_pan_already_soaked_overnight/

## Buying signals

- **buyers are ready to purchase, some asking for it as a gift** (3 mentions)
  - "Just asked Santa!" TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@katerobbllc/video/7703308335168113934
  - "Will buy literally ANYTHING you recommend at this point because I knowwwww it’s gonna be good !!!!" TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@katerobbllc/video/7703308335168113934
- **sale and discount codes drive purchases** (3 mentions)
  - "You don’t want to miss out on these deals!! Use link in bio or code BritneyH to shop the sale! #caraway #cookware #cookwareset #kitchenwares #cooking @Caraway H…" TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@britneyhollingsworth/video/7707671224998006047
  - "Let this be your sign to buy some high quality, non toxic @Caraway Home pots and pans while they’re on sale 👏🏼 #friendsofcaraway #ad #nontoxic #blackfridaysal…" TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@morgannbushh/video/7708048144948333837
- **people are upgrading from scratched old cookware to this set** (3 mentions)
  - "Your sign to upgrade the scratched-up cookware situation 👀 This Caraway 12-piece set is non-stick, oven safe, works on all stovetops, and comes with storage. L…" TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@meganhil/video/7707653857374915871
  - "FINALLY, the Caraway cookware upgrade you’ve been waiting for! #caraway #TikTokShopBlackFriday #CarawayPartner #cookware #nonstickpans" TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@trulygladgirls/video/7707326103731424542
- **considering buying after seeing an honest review** (3 mentions)
  - "Could you do a review? You’re the first person to actual show me these and now I’m invested!! Trying to buy my first pan set x" TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@rialapae/video/7680976525860162830
  - "i fear you have influenced me" TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@rialapae/video/7680976525860162830
- **wants the set for a birthday or as a gift** (2 mentions)
  - "I want caraway cookware for my birthday https://t.co/lVHXxi5kKD" X https://x.com/KeyKeytoMarz/status/2112333023207109082
  - "Trust that I WILL be buying this set for myself" TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@katerobbllc/video/7703308335168113934
- **waiting for a sale or holiday discount before buying** (1 mention)
  - "I'll buy at christmas time, when they go on sale" TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@rialapae/video/7680976525860162830
- **using a gift card to get stainless steel instead of ceramic** (1 mention)
  - "Got a Caraway Gift Card - what should I do?. Hi folks. I won a Caraway "set" in my work's holiday raffle. Turns out, that means just sending me a $500 gift card. I've read all the posts about how the ceramic pans aren't …" Reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/cookware/comments/1pzxrh8/got_a_caraway_gift_card_what_should_i_do/

## Compared with other brands

- **compared with stainless steel like All-Clad at similar prices** (3 mentions)
  - "Im looking at these too vs all clad very similar price points id love an honest review by someone not sponsored" TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@rialapae/video/7680976525860162830
  - "I have heard from many people that after a year they turn to crap. Invest in stainless steel like allclad" Reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/UninfluencedReviews/comments/1sjhjol/feedback_on_caraway_cookware_are_they_any_good/ofrwp31/
- **compared with cast iron and carbon steel as better alternatives** (3 mentions)
  - "I call bullshit on one of her family members having cancer. She literally asked chat gpt for some ideas how to shill that cookware. And if that’s true that someone in her family had cancer.. well she’s still disgusting c…" Reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/BrookeRaybouldSnark/comments/1ve7mkh/weekly_snark_8389/
  - "Try a seasoned cast iron skillet. They are the best, really." TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@sandybeach731/video/7706639319284321567
- **compared with stainless steel, which is seen as the better long-term investment** (2 mentions)
  - "I’ve had mine for years and still enjoy using them but stainless is the better investment." Reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/UninfluencedReviews/comments/1sjhjol/feedback_on_caraway_cookware_are_they_any_good/ofshcho/
  - "After 5 years with my @Caraway Home ceramic cookware, I finally made the switch to stainless steel 👀✨ I had such a hard time finding videos that actually showe…" TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@rialapae/video/7680976525860162830
- **switching to stainless steel after years with Caraway** (2 mentions)
  - "So your pans only lasted 5 years and you decided to buy the same brand?" TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@rialapae/video/7680976525860162830
  - "I’m 5 years into mine as well and definitely will get my stainless steel set next" TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@rialapae/video/7680976525860162830
- **lumped with Hexclad and Always Pan as disappointing nonstick** (2 mentions)
  - "Anyone here actually using titanium cookware long term?. I’ve gone through a HexClad, an Always Pan, and two Caraways in about 4 years. Every single one started sticking after about 6 months, usually right in the center …" Reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/cookware/comments/1xhj435/anyone_here_actually_using_titanium_cookware_long/
  - "Its essentially stainless yes. No it doesnt get more nonstick. You just get better at cooking. I gotta say thats rough, being scammed by Hexclad, Our Place, Caraway and now whatever Titanium pan you got. Just learn stain…" Reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/cookware/comments/1xhj435/anyone_here_actually_using_titanium_cookware_long/19rrwwz0q7pz7/
- **compared with cheaper knockoffs from Sam's Club that fail within a year** (1 mention)
  - "I’ve had mine for about 2 years now, and they still work great! I actually replaced the OXO stainless steel set with them, because the OXO ones would heat up so unevenly. My parents have the knock offs from Sam’s Club, a…" Reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/UninfluencedReviews/comments/1sjhjol/feedback_on_caraway_cookware_are_they_any_good/oft19sd/
- **cheaper Ninja stainless set chosen instead** (1 mention)
  - "I was looking at these but I couldn’t do the $600-800 😭 and I wanted a big set not buy separately 😵‍💫 I got my ninja stainless steel set for under $300😭 I love them, I also use princess house a lot too" TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@rialapae/video/7680976525860162830

## What people want next

- **users want a non-stick pan that actually lasts and keeps its coating** (3 mentions)
  - "Yep. Total waste of my money. I had such high hopes for them and they suck 😡" Reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/cookware/comments/1tpbk43/caraway_pans_can_eat_my_actual_ass/oohbbw5/
  - "Caraway. After browsing a bit it seems like the consensus is this brand is made in China and sucks. They don't have a phone support option of course and I understand it's a 1 year warranty (spouse made the choice 1.5 yea…" Reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/cookware/comments/1qvx9hl/caraway/
- **users want better customer support, including phone support and honored warranties** (3 mentions)
  - "That would upset me too! Can you contact the company?" TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@sandybeach731/video/7706639319284321567
  - "Caraway. After browsing a bit it seems like the consensus is this brand is made in China and sucks. They don't have a phone support option of course and I understand it's a 1 year warranty (spouse made the choice 1.5 yea…" Reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/cookware/comments/1qvx9hl/caraway/
- **wants an unsponsored, honest review video** (3 mentions)
  - "Im looking at these too vs all clad very similar price points id love an honest review by someone not sponsored" TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@rialapae/video/7680976525860162830
  - "Could you do a review? You’re the first person to actual show me these and now I’m invested!! Trying to buy my first pan set x" TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@rialapae/video/7680976525860162830
- **users want tips on cleaning stains off the pans** (1 mention)
  - "Maybe try barkeeper’s friend to get those stains off. That stuff works miracles." TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@sandybeach731/video/7706639319284321567
- **wants a review of the stainless steel line after use** (1 mention)
  - "Omg I didn’t know they had stainless steel 😍😍 please make a review once you have used them a few times" TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@rialapae/video/7680976525860162830

## Quotes

> I received a set as a wedding gift and, initially, really enjoyed them. However, they are not meant to last more than 2-3 years, based on how much you use them. Our daily use frying pan began to lose its nonstick after about ~20 months. A friend contacted their customer service about the same thing, and they basically said the pans aren’t meant to last forever. A bit of planned obsolescence. Also,…
> -- u/Sad_Somewhere3916 on Reddit, https://www.reddit.com/r/UninfluencedReviews/comments/1sjhjol/feedback_on_caraway_cookware_are_they_any_good/ofrxcpp/

> Deceptive messaging re: Caraway pan. I have been happily ignoring HF "come back" emails/offers for more than a year now after canceling due to quality and boring recipes. This week the skillet I use most kicked the bucket, and coincidentally I had the Caraway pan email in my inbox. Okay, I'll bite. Free Caraway Fry Pan! the email said. Free Caray Fry Pan! the promo banner on the sign-up screen sai…
> -- u/HistoricalScience748 on Reddit, https://www.reddit.com/r/hellofresh/comments/1w2ncrs/deceptive_messaging_re_caraway_pan/

> Got a long pan, it warped on the first use instead of laying flat.
> -- u/Interesting_Ad1378 on Reddit, https://www.reddit.com/r/UninfluencedReviews/comments/1sjhjol/feedback_on_caraway_cookware_are_they_any_good/oftl8ra/

> Caraway does not honor their one year warranty. One of our pans was not "non-stick", however they refused to replace it with only 3 months of usage.
> -- @berettaguy7445 on YouTube, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q4cdoKd1Dcc&lc=UgxCYqKbn743xX1VOuR4AaABAg

> Caraway. After browsing a bit it seems like the consensus is this brand is made in China and sucks. They don't have a phone support option of course and I understand it's a 1 year warranty (spouse made the choice 1.5 years ago to buy) and half annoyed at them and half at myself for not doing any research. One pan is literally degrading with gouge marks on the edges. They must have some weird "egg …
> -- u/VictorVonD278 on Reddit, https://www.reddit.com/r/cookware/comments/1qvx9hl/caraway/

> Also looks like a Caraway pot, the most ‘influencer’ of cookware.
> -- u/gorgeous_bastard on Reddit, https://v.redd.it/q1eqt17yislh1